• Reset your password

Main navigation

  • Home
  • About
    • Methodology
    • A Brief History of PRE
    • Funding and Support
  • Evaluations
  • Plants
  • Organizations
  • Community
  • Projects

User account menu

  • Log in
PRE — Plant Risk Evaluator

Erythrostemon gilliesii -- Arizona

Primary tabs

  • View
  • Issues

Evaluation Summary


photo by Ron Vanderhoff

Evaluation Date:  2022-08-31

Screener:  Michael Chamberland
 
Plant:  Erythrostemon gilliesii
Common Name(s):
Bird of paradise shrub

State:  Arizona

PRE Score:  11
Questions Answered:  20
Screener Confidence (%):  57

Executive Summary

Erythrostemon gilliesii is cultivated as an ornamental for its flowers. It can escape cultivation and can be found in wild areas in dryland settings. The plant has a puzzling distribution in many parts of the Globe. Unlike most escapes from horticulture, this plant, at least in the southwest USA, is not seen expanding from urban settings, but instead can be found in remote areas far from habitation. It is often seen along roadsides in areas where it would be unlikely to be planted. The plant is available in the horticulture trade, but it is not intensively used. This suggests the plant may be spreading in wild areas through means which are not advanced by its horticulture use. The method by which it spreads so widely is not apparent. While Erythrostemon gilliesii has proven to be weedy in many parts of the USA and other dry regions of the Globe, it has received a low PRE score here on the basis of not showing significant impact where it has naturalized.

Climate Matching Map

Attachment Size
ClimateMatch_AZ_Erythrostemon_gilliesii.pdf (1.08 MB) 1.08 MB

1. Question 1

Yes
1
Very High
Erythrostemon gilliesii is native to areas of Argentina and Uruguay where it occurs in savanna and woodland habitats. Widely planted in the southwestern U.S. and sometimes naturalizing in areas with sufficient rainfall (DELEP, 2021). The plant is noted in regional floras for Arizona (Carnahan & Davis, 2020)(Roll, 2020). The USDA Plants Database (USDA, 2021) shows E. gilliesii occurring in California, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, New Mexico, Texas, Georgia and Puerto Rico. In South Africa, E. gilliesii is classified as a 1b = invasive species that must be controlled in accordance with a national management programme, and cannot be traded or otherwise allowed to spread (Williams et al, 2021). The plant is introduced in the Canary Islands (Verloove, 2017), the Iberian Peninsula of Spain (Aymerich & Saez, 2019), Italy (Stinca, 2021), Libya (Saaed et al, 2021), Sardinia (Puddu et al, 2016), Chile (Santilli, 2018), Mexico (Ruida-Torres et al, 2022) (Castillon et al, 2005), and most of the states in Australia (McCune, 1998).
2021. “Erythrostemon Gilliesii”. https://cals.arizona.edu/desertlegumeprogram/legume-taxa/erythrostemon-gilliesii.
Carnahan, Susan Davis. 2020. “Flora of the Salero Ranch, Santa Cruz County, Arizona”. Canotia 16: 83.
Roll, Chris M. 2020. “Vascular Plants of the Pat Hills Desert Grassland, Southeast Arizona”. Phytoneuron 44: 14.
“USDA Plants Database”. 2021. https://plants.usda.gov/home/plantProfile?symbol=LERE5.
Williams, Vivienne L., Amy Burness, Ewa M. Wojtasik, and Marcus J. Byrne. 2021. “Dataset, Including a Photo-Guide, of Alien Plants Sold in Traditional Medicine Markets and Healthcare Outlets in Three South African Cities, Specifically by Traders of Indian, West African, East African, and Chinese Origin”. Data in Brief 38: 107395. doi:10.1016/j.dib.2021.107395.
Verloove, FILIP. 2017. “New Xenophytes from the Canary Islands (Gran Canaria and Tenerife; Spain)”. Acta Botanica Croatica 76: 120-31. doi:10.1515/botcro-2017-0013.
Aymerich, Pere, and Llorenç Sáez. 2019. “Checklist of the Vascular Alien Flora of Catalonia (northeastern Iberian Peninsula, Spain)”. Mediterranean Botany 40: 215-42. doi:10.5209/mbot.63608.
Stinca, Adriano, Carmelo Maria Musarella, Leonardo Rosati, Valentina Lucia Astrid Laface, Wolfgang Licht, Emanuele Fanfarillo, Robert Philipp Wagensommer, et al. 2021. “Italian Vascular Flora: New Findings, Updates and Exploration of Floristic Similarities Between Regions”. Diversity 13: 600. doi:10.3390/d13110600.
Saaed, Manam W. B., Yacoub M. El-Barasi, and Rebeh O. Rahil. 2021. “An Updated Checklist and Quantitative Analysis of the Marmarica Plateau Flora, in the North-Eastern Part of Libya”. Phytotaxa 509. doi:10.11646/phytotaxa.509.1.1.
Puddu, Selena, Lina Podda, Olga Mayoral, Alain Delage, Laetitia Hugot, Yohan Petit, and Gianluigi Bacchetta. 2016. “Comparative Analysis of the Alien Vascular Flora of Sardinia and Corsica”. Notulae Botanicae Horti Agrobotanici Cluj-Napoca 44: 337-46. doi:10.15835/nbha44210491.
Santilli, Ludovica, Sergio A. Castro, Javier A. Figueroa, Nicole Guerrero, Cristian Ray, Mario Romero-Mieres, Gloria Rojas, and Nicolás Lavandero. 2018. “Exotic Species Predominates in the Urban Woody Flora of Central Chile”. Gayana Botánica 75: 568-88. doi:10.4067/S0717-66432018000200568.
Rueda-Torres, J. R., De León-Pesqueira, and A. B. Gatica-Colima. 2022. “Fabaceas of the Flora and Fauna Protection Area Medanos de Samalayuca, Chihuahua, Mexico”. Polibotánica, 1-12. doi:10.18387/polibotanica.53.1.
Estrada Castillón, Eduardo, José Ángel Villarreal Quintanilla, and Enrique Jurado. 2005. “Leguminosas del Norte del Estado de Nuevo León, México”. Acta Botánica Mexicana, 1-18. http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_abstract\&pid=S0187-71512005000400001\&lng=es\&nrm=iso\&tlng=es.
McCune, Wiecek \& S. 1998. “PlantNET - New South Wales FloraOnline - Caesalpinia Gilliesii (Wall. Ex Hook.) D.Dietr”. https://plantnet.rbgsyd.nsw.gov.au/cgi-bin/NSWfl.pl?page=nswfl\&lvl=sp\&name=Caesalpinia gilliesii.

2. Question 2

Yes
2
Very High
In addition to being naturalized in Arizona, Erythrostemon gilliesii is naturalized in the following regions which are a climate match for Arizona: California, Nevada, Utah, New Mexico, Texas (USDA, 2021) South Africa (Williams et al, 2021); the Iberian Peninsula of Spain (Aymerich & Saez, 2019); Chihuahua, Mexico (Ruida-Torres et al, 2022) Nuevo Leon, Mexico (Castillon et al, 2005); and most of the states in Australia (McCune, 1998).
“USDA Plants Database”. 2021. https://plants.usda.gov/home/plantProfile?symbol=LERE5.
Williams, Vivienne L., Amy Burness, Ewa M. Wojtasik, and Marcus J. Byrne. 2021. “Dataset, Including a Photo-Guide, of Alien Plants Sold in Traditional Medicine Markets and Healthcare Outlets in Three South African Cities, Specifically by Traders of Indian, West African, East African, and Chinese Origin”. Data in Brief 38: 107395. doi:10.1016/j.dib.2021.107395.
Aymerich, Pere, and Llorenç Sáez. 2019. “Checklist of the Vascular Alien Flora of Catalonia (northeastern Iberian Peninsula, Spain)”. Mediterranean Botany 40: 215-42. doi:10.5209/mbot.63608.
Rueda-Torres, J. R., De León-Pesqueira, and A. B. Gatica-Colima. 2022. “Fabaceas of the Flora and Fauna Protection Area Medanos de Samalayuca, Chihuahua, Mexico”. Polibotánica, 1-12. doi:10.18387/polibotanica.53.1.
Estrada Castillón, Eduardo, José Ángel Villarreal Quintanilla, and Enrique Jurado. 2005. “Leguminosas del Norte del Estado de Nuevo León, México”. Acta Botánica Mexicana, 1-18. http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_abstract\&pid=S0187-71512005000400001\&lng=es\&nrm=iso\&tlng=es.
McCune, Wiecek \& S. 1998. “PlantNET - New South Wales FloraOnline - Caesalpinia Gilliesii (Wall. Ex Hook.) D.Dietr”. https://plantnet.rbgsyd.nsw.gov.au/cgi-bin/NSWfl.pl?page=nswfl\&lvl=sp\&name=Caesalpinia gilliesii.

3. Question 3

No
0
Medium
Although naturalized in many parts of the world, Erythrostemon gilliesii is typically described as a cultivation escape, environmental weed, garden thug, naturalized, or weed (Thomas, 2017). Evidence of impact is listed as "No" by GBIF (2022). The Plant has not been documented reaching the level of impact to meet the definition of invasive used by the PRE. The plant is listed as a NEMBA Category 1b plant by South Africa Invasives. The NEMBA Categories are regulatory categories, with this listing indicating the species must be controlled (SA Invasives, 2021). The fact sheet provided by South Africa Invasives does not elaborate on the impact or characteristics of Erythrostemon occurrence in the country. It is uncertain whether this meets the definition of invasive used by the PRE.
Thomas, Philip A. 2017. “Caesalpinia Gilliesii Information from the Global Compendium of Weeds (GCW)”. http://www.hear.org/gcw/species/caesalpinia_gilliesii/.
2022. “Global Biodiversity Information Facility”. https://www.gbif.org/.
SA, Invasives. 2021. “Bird of Paradise Flower”. https://invasives.org.za/fact-sheet/bird-of-paradise-flower/.

4. Question 4

No
0
Medium
Although naturalized in many parts of the world, Erythrostemon gilliesii is described as a cultivation escape, environmental weed, garden thug, naturalized, or weed (Thomas, 2017). This includes occurrance in regions with a similar climate to Arizona, but there the plant has not been clearly documented to reach the level of impact to meet the definition of invasive used by the PRE.
Thomas, Philip A. 2017. “Caesalpinia Gilliesii Information from the Global Compendium of Weeds (GCW)”. http://www.hear.org/gcw/species/caesalpinia_gilliesii/.

5. Question 5

Yes
1
Medium
Erythrostemon is a small genus previously classified in the formerly large genus Caesalpinia. The Global Compendium of Weeds (CABI, 2007) lists this species under Caesalpinia. It also lists Caesalpinia decapetala as invasive for climate-matching regions of Australia and South Africa. Caesalpinia spinosa is naturalized to climate-matching regions of California, but not known to be invasive there (Wojciechowski & McClintock, 2012).
Rojas-Sandoval, Julissa. 2007. “CABI Invasive Species Compendium”. http://www.cabi.org/isc/$\#$tab1-nav.
Wojciechowski, MF, and E McClintock. 2012. “Jepson EFlora: Taxon Page for Caesalpinia Gilliesii” 2022. https://ucjeps.berkeley.edu/eflora/eflora_display.php?tid=16498.

6. Question 6

Yes
2
Medium
Apparently more than half of the places the plant is native or naturalized are within the climate match map for Arizona.
No references cited.

7. Question 7

No
0
Low
Said to compete with indigenous vegetation in South Africa (SA Invasives, 2021). The naturalized occurrence of the shrubs are usually sporadic in distribution and the plant possess a wide, open branching structure unlikely to shade out other plants (personal observation in the southwest USA, also see photos on Calflora, 2022).
SA, Invasives. 2021. “Bird of Paradise Flower”. https://invasives.org.za/fact-sheet/bird-of-paradise-flower/.
Calflora,. 2022. “Calflora - Caesalpinia Gilliesii”. https://www.calflora.org/app/taxon?crn=1229.

8. Question 8

No
0
Low
No published information on fire effects was found. The sporadic occurrence of the naturalized plants, without forming dense stands (personal observation in the southwest USA) suggests a low potential to carry wildfire.
No references cited.

9. Question 9

Yes
1
Medium
The seeds and the green seed pods of this plant are toxic, provoking severe vomiting and other abdominal symptoms (SA Invasives, 2021). The green fruits and seeds of this species can cause gastrointestinal upset if eaten (DELEP, 2021). Toxic to cats and dogs (Gardenia.net, 2022). The first two references would seem to refer to toxicity to humans, while the latter reference is to toxicity to pets.
SA, Invasives. 2021. “Bird of Paradise Flower”. https://invasives.org.za/fact-sheet/bird-of-paradise-flower/.
2021. “Erythrostemon Gilliesii”. https://cals.arizona.edu/desertlegumeprogram/legume-taxa/erythrostemon-gilliesii.
.net, Gardenia. 2022. “Caesalpinia Gilliesii (Bird of Paradise Shrub)”. https://www.gardenia.net/plant/caesalpinia-gilliesii.

10. Question 10

No
0
Low
The naturalized occurrence of the shrubs are usually sporadic in distribution and possessing a wide, open branching structure (personal observation, also see photos on Calflora, 2022).
Calflora,. 2022. “Calflora - Caesalpinia Gilliesii”. https://www.calflora.org/app/taxon?crn=1229.

11. Question 11

No
0
Low
No information available suggests natural vegetative spread. The character of the plant does not suggest the likelihood (personal observation).
No references cited.

12. Question 12

No
0
Medium
No information available suggests natural vegetative spread. The character of the plant does not suggest the likelihood (personal observation).
No references cited.

13. Question 13

Yes
1
High
Plants can volunteer from seeds in locations where there is sufficient moisture and sometimes spread into natural areas (DELEP, 2021). Propagate by seed or softwood cuttings (Gardenia.net, 2022).
2021. “Erythrostemon Gilliesii”. https://cals.arizona.edu/desertlegumeprogram/legume-taxa/erythrostemon-gilliesii.
.net, Gardenia. 2022. “Caesalpinia Gilliesii (Bird of Paradise Shrub)”. https://www.gardenia.net/plant/caesalpinia-gilliesii.

14. Question 14

No
0
Medium
The plant is a shrub with a low to moderate number of flowering branches (personal observation). Fruits are legumes containing a limited number of seeds. Seeds are large, 9mm in length (Kheloufi et al, 2018) and must be produced in smaller numbers than tiny seeds would. By inference, not a copious seed producer.
Kheloufi, Abdenour, Lahouaria Mansouri, Nada Aziz, Meriem Sahnoune, Sarra Boukemiche, and Boutheina Ababsa. 2018. “Breaking Seed Coat Dormancy of Six Tree Species”. REFORESTA, 4-14. doi:10.21750/REFOR.5.02.48.

15. Question 15

Yes
1
High
A germination trial recorded 82.5% germination of untreated (control) set of seeds (Kheloufi et al, 2018).
Kheloufi, Abdenour, Lahouaria Mansouri, Nada Aziz, Meriem Sahnoune, Sarra Boukemiche, and Boutheina Ababsa. 2018. “Breaking Seed Coat Dormancy of Six Tree Species”. REFORESTA, 4-14. doi:10.21750/REFOR.5.02.48.

16. Question 16

Yes
1
Very Low
It is reported to be fast growing (Gardenia.net, 2022). Being a shrub, by inference it is possible it can reach a reproductive state within five years.
.net, Gardenia. 2022. “Caesalpinia Gilliesii (Bird of Paradise Shrub)”. https://www.gardenia.net/plant/caesalpinia-gilliesii.

17. Question 17

Yes
1
Medium
Flowering Period: Almost throughout the year, at least in Karachi (Anonymous, 2022). Flowering extends from spring into autumn (DELEP, 2021).
2022. “Caesalpinia Gilliesii in Flora of Pakistan @ Efloras.Org”. http://www.efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id=5\&taxon_id=242412427.
2021. “Erythrostemon Gilliesii”. https://cals.arizona.edu/desertlegumeprogram/legume-taxa/erythrostemon-gilliesii.

18. Question 18

No
0
Low
The plant's reported toxicity and dry dehiscent seed pods (Gardenia.net, 2022) count against the likelihood of seed dispersed by ungulates. The large size of the seeds (Kheloufi et al, 2018) makes them unlikely to be dispersed in the crop of birds. The seed pods dry and split, sometimes explosively (Gardenia.net, 2022) suggesting a mechanical means of short-distance seed dispersal.
No references cited.

19. Question 19

No
0
Low
Seeds are large and smooth (Kheloufi et al, 2018) with no obvious adaptation for traveling by wind or water.
Kheloufi, Abdenour, Lahouaria Mansouri, Nada Aziz, Meriem Sahnoune, Sarra Boukemiche, and Boutheina Ababsa. 2018. “Breaking Seed Coat Dormancy of Six Tree Species”. REFORESTA, 4-14. doi:10.21750/REFOR.5.02.48.

20. Question 20

No
0
Low
The seed pods dry and split, sometimes explosively (Gardenia.net, 2022) suggesting a mechanical means of short-distance seed dispersal. The occurrence of the plant along roadsides suggests the seeds might be moved in the tread of vehicle tires. However, no information is available on how the plants seeds are dispersed over long distances to reach remote areas.
.net, Gardenia. 2022. “Caesalpinia Gilliesii (Bird of Paradise Shrub)”. https://www.gardenia.net/plant/caesalpinia-gilliesii.

Total PRE Score

11
20
57

PRE Score Legend

The PRE Score is calculated by adding the point totals for each (answered) question.

< 13 : Low Potential Risk
13 - 15 : Moderate Potential Risk
> 15 : High Potential Risk

Questions Answered Legend

It is important to answer at least 16 questions to consider a PRE Score as "valid".

≥ 16 : Valid (80% or more questions answered)
≤ 15 : Invalid (not enough questions answered)

Evaluation Credits and Citation


Screener:  Michael Chamberland

 

Below is a recommend citation when referencing this evaluation in other works:

Chamberland, Michael. "Erythrostemon gilliesii -- Arizona" Plant Risk Evaluator (PRE) published 2022-08-31 https://pretool.org/evaluations/1788

 


Please cite this evaluation. We need your support here!

PRE Evaluations take a long time to research, so please credit this site and evaluation appropriately.


Evaluation Reviewers

reviewed on 2022-12-05
Jutta Burger reviewed on 2022-10-10
Nicole Valentine reviewed on 2022-10-07

 

Associated Project

2022 Western IPM Grant Project

"Expanding Continuity and Capacity in Invasive Plant Risk Assessments across Western States" is a continuation of the successful 2021 project titled "Building Continuity Across State Invasvie Plant Lists: Evaluating Invasive Risk of Horticultural Plants." Both 2021 and 2022's projects are funded by the Western Integrated Pest Management Center. Project partners for this year inclue the California Invasive Plant Council, PlantRight, The University of Arizona, Western Invasive Species Network, Pacific Northwest Invasive Species Council, the Yurok Tribe, and Nevada State Parks. 


 

Associated Organizations, Agencies, and Institutions

The University of Arizona

 

Copyright © 2025 PRETool.org - All rights reserved